If it's true that bad money can drive out good, then the reverse can
happen too. Witness Zimbabwe, which as recently as July 2008 was
experiencing inflation at an annual rate of 231 million percent. This
February inflation clocked in at a 3% annual rate, thanks to an
experiment in U.S. dollarization that has achieved what price controls
never could. There's a broader monetary lesson here.
When the country became independent in
1980, the Zimbabwe dollar was worth about $1.25. Inflation rose
steadily by double digits under Robert Mugabe until the late 1990s, by
which time his land confiscation from white farmers had crippled food
production. To continue funding the government?and its debts?in the face
of plummeting tax revenue, the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe cranked up its
printing presses, and inflation rose to triple digits by 2001.
By the end of 2008, consumer prices
were nearly doubling from one day to the next. The government in Harare
tried price controls, which merely exacerbated the shortages caused by
Mugabe's expropriations. And the government periodically redenominated
the Zimbabwean dollar, scribbling out zeroes by fiat, to little effect.
In January 2009 it introduced the Zimbabwe 100 trillion dollar note,
worth about $30.
Reserve
Bank Governor Gideon Gono declared then that "the Zimbabwe dollar will
not be overtaken by any other currency, formally or otherwise, now or at
any point in the future." Except it already had. For years businesses
had made many products available only in U.S. dollars or South African
rands.
By April 2009 the government had
stopped resisting, legalized the use of foreign money, and suspended the
Zimbabwe dollar. The move essentially abandoned an independent monetary
policy, but Zimbabwe's citizens could suddenly maintain their assets in
currencies they could trust. Inflation began to fall to rates
consistent with U.S. central bank policy.
The Zimbabwe economy has started to
show other signs of life, such as store shelves that are full again.
According to the IMF, economic growth hit 5.9% last year and is
projected at 4.5% this year, after a decade of contraction. With a
stable currency, more citizens can now earn enough to buy what they
need, and even save money that might not instantly lose its value.
In nearly all other respects,
Zimbabwe's business climate remains a nightmare. Property rights,
investor protections and contract enforcement remain negligible, to say
nothing of Harare's ongoing political repressions. To compound Mugabe's
disastrous brand of "black empowerment," the government is making noises
to implement the "Indigenization Act," which would require foreign
mining companies to cede 51% of their shares to a sovereign wealth fund.
Trust Uncle Bob to demonstrate that
there is much ruin in a government. But Zimbabwe's successful experience
with dollarization reminds us again of Milton Friedman's point that
inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon. Sound money?a
means of exchange that people trust?is essential to economic growth.
Dollarization has given Zimbabweans a chance to eke out a living despite
the continuing depredations of their political leaders.
Source: The Wall Street Journal,
Posted by IAMES